Fifty Shades of Grumpy Reviews


I really got excited about turning my idea for Fifty Shades of Grumpy into a novel.  It could even become a major motion picture!

Fifty Review1

I already had the basic formula sketched out.  I then turned that sketch into an outline.  Finally I set to work on a preliminary draft.  Before going any further I thought it best to send the draft to selected reviewers to get input.  I got back some of their comments and I see that I need to do a little more work.


I have never read anything like it and hope I never do again.                            –New York Times


If you only read one book this year, don’t make it this one.                  –Washington Post


This is a book for which the words “out of print” will be a blessing.           –Chicago Tribune


Spectacular!  Sexy and erotic!  Brilliant!  A sensational read!                             These are the words I would use to describe some other book but not this one. –Los Angeles Times


The book should be made of toilet paper so that it would at least be useful for something.                                                                                                                    –Barron’s


Thinking of all the starving children in the world is preferable to reading this nonsense.                                                                                                                             –The Wall Street Journal


This book sucks!                                                                                                                    –Rolling Stone


Mixing the book with sewage would improve it.                                                         –The New York Review of Books


Yet another indication that America never mastered the English language. –Guardian (UK)


The critics have spoken, the bastards!

Fifty Shades of Grumpy,                                                                                               NOT coming to a book store near you anytime soon;                                             NOT to be a major motion picture.


Fifty Review2

39 thoughts on “Fifty Shades of Grumpy Reviews

  1. I love these “reviews” more than anything else I’ve read today. Although I think I have one that could top yours. I’ve written a memoir about family dysfunction, Tales From the Family Crypt, about what happened as each of my parents and my husband’s parents died. While the parents are now gone, the adult children are still alive and well. Well, maybe not so well, as you’ll see. My brother-in-law, one of the characters (I use the term not loosely) in my story, has been stalking my book reviews on Amazon. He comments on every one, all the good ones and the other few negative ones written by other family members. His reviews are hilarious but Amazon keeps deleting them for inappropriate content. My favorite, one you could add to your list:

    Christ 1 star
    Hitler 5 stars

    Seriously, I couldn’t make this up. But I will follow your blog to get the laughs I need to continue dealing with these characters. Thanks.

  2. Maybe the reviewers simply thought you didn’t have enough content for ’50 Shades’ – perhaps ’25 Shades of Grumpy’ would be received better.

  3. Diane Henders is right: you need to accentuate the positive. Fifty Shades of Grumpy is a multi-purpose book; read it, use it as a door stop and as mulch. For those pounding 5 Hour Energy: do all three at once!

  4. Oh, come on, don’t lose hope! It’s all about spin-doctoring. For example, I’d say that The New York Review of Books quite definitively stated that Fifty Shades of Grumpy is so good it would even improve sewage. Spin, baby, spin!

  5. Reblogged this on fictionwriterwithablog and commented:
    As part of “Re-blog Wednesday”, I chose Curmudgeon-as-Large. I chose him for 2 reasons, a) I love the word curmudgeon, and he does it so well; and, b) who can resist a muppet? Plus, I loathe 50 shades of gray. 50 shades of Grumpy, that I would read 🙂

  6. Some of the worst written books in history (including one with a very similar name to your – have you thought of suing the author for infringement?!?!?) have sold millions of copies. I suggest you toss in regular bits of foul language (“Holy crap”, “Daggnabit”, “Up yours” come to mind), a scene or two of pain you’ve been asked to sign your agreement to (perhaps we could watch your hero [yourself?] squirm helplessly in a dentist’s chair or be physically ‘manipulated’ while strapped to a chiropractor’s table) and I guarantee – copies will fly off the shelves. Don’t give up. There’s an audience out there for this book. 🙂

Leave a Reply But Wipe Your Feet First

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s